With less than three weeks until the 48 Hour Film Project competition, we carried out tests today with a portable Wafian recorder acting as a digital cinema playback server to the Sony 4K projector. The results were stunning. The Wafian HR-F1 is a very convenient way to do HD presentation, using this tiny form-factor to deliver 1080 24PsF over HDSDI to the Sony 4K projector. We played a range of scanned film and SI-2K source material, all looked great. But as we are effectively renting the theater for these tests, I was able to do things that may not be very acceptable at $10 per movie ticket, like standing 2' from the 34'+ screen looking at the pixel structure of the image -- something I always want to do with digital projection (with film I don't need to see the grain that close.) At 4K, even the first row can't see the pixels -- this is a nice projection format. I'm hoping we have many HD+ submissions for this competition, as we want to help SD projection come to an end ASAP.
Monday, June 25, 2007
Thursday, June 14, 2007
A CineForm first : driving the 48 Hour Film Project to HD and beyond
For each year the 48 Hour Film Project has come to San Diego, CineForm has entered a team; we even won a prize last year (see the full story for 2006.) After each event, we can't help thinking that CineForm needs to sponsor this competition, as these cutting edge indie filmmakers are our target market. But as we lack the funding of past heavy weight sponsors Avid and Panasonic, we had to be inventive.
This year, we are making the San Diego division of the 48 Hour Film Project the coolest of the 60+ international city circuit, by being the first city to present HD by providing services in exchange for CineForm sponsorship. CineForm is providing all the back-end format conversion and mastering of all 40 to 50 films to 1080p HD, all within 2-3 days of the competition's completion. Then CineForm, with the help of Wafian, is providing the projection server and staffing to present all the submissions on a Sony 4K projector at the Hillcrest Landmark theatres. To upconvert 50 short films from a huge range of formats to 1080p for projection is a marathon project in itself, plus we'll be entering our own team two days before, so we'll be flat out for few days.
Why are we doing this? Because we can. With our tools now being cross platform and CineForm being an ideal project format (yes, we have a digital theatre group adopting CineForm over the more pricey JPEG2000) we have all the tools to pull this off. Plus, it's going to be a lot of fun, particularly to see our work on a 4K screen.
If you are an HD indie filmmaker and you're in or near the San Diego area, you should consider joining this competition to see your work in its full resolution on the big screen. Sign up while you can.
Friday, June 01, 2007
CineForm RAW interview at NAB '07
Digital Production BuZZ has posted an interview between Jim Mathers and myself that occurred at this past NAB. While I never feel completely comfortable when someone points a camera and mike at me and says "Tell us about all this," I think it came out okay. My monologue covers the beginnings of CineForm RAW for digital cinema acquisition to today's integrated 3D look system within the SI-2K cameras. My section is only 9 minutes and it can be found at the 20m:20s mark of the podcast.
Here is the direct link to the mp3 of the interview. Also, check out the complete show notes for the entire podcast.
Tuesday, May 29, 2007
Silicon Imaging demo online
Jason Rodriguez of Silicon Imaging has posted a excellent demo of the user interface controlling the SI-2K digital cinema camera. It shows some of the advantages in using an embedded Intel CPU with a video camera. Click the image to jump to the demo.
Note: when he is talking about compression level, and the display says "Very High," he is actually talking about the quality level. Very high quality and very high compression tend to have opposite meanings. :) At the "Very High" setting, the compression is a light 5:1.![]()
Wednesday, April 25, 2007
CineForm 444 vs HDCAM-SR revisited
During NAB, I had an honored visitor to the CineForm booth, Hugo Gaggiono, CTO of Sony's Broadcast Production System Division. Unfortunately, I was not there to meet him, so he spent time with Jeff Youel of Wafian discussing our recent test with HDCAM-SR, and how we were able to achieve the results we did (the reason for his visit.) I later tried to follow up with Hugo at the Sony booth, but I had no luck with paging him. Pity, as I now had data as to why CineForm did so well against his format.
That same day, I answered the challenge for an outsider (Russell Branch of InnoMedia Systems Ltd.) to evaluate the test materials comparing CineForm to HDCAM-SR. Russell had been following the discussion on the Cinematographer's Mailing List (CML) regarding this experiment, and kindly offered to perform the quality measuring tests himself. It's likely Russell had access to
the OmniTech picture quality anaylsis device, and along with some help from the OmniTech guys we ran a DVD full of frames through their analysis. Their conclusion was very similar to our own, and it also showed the HDCAM-SR doing worse on the StEM, just as we had found. The main difference in this test (other than the OmniTech being much faster than my own analysis), was that the OmniTech device could show us why SR's quality dropped for StEM footage.
Often for testing CineForm I would gain up the difference (between compressed and the source) to show what has changed during the encoding.
This photo is the OmniTech showing that very difference, subtracting the CineForm compressed images from the uncompressed source, revealing an effectively grey frame (no significant differences.) However, I never did this test with HDCAM-SR; after all, I can't fix any issues I might find, so the test never occurred to me. The OmniTech operator had no such issues; he didn't know what compression he was testing and was therefore completely unbiased (sorry, I didn't write down his name.) When he flipped on the differencing, there was a distinct image within the frame -- he even suspected it was HDCAM-SR based on the images revealed in the differencing.
The brighter image parts of the display, indicating a larger encoding error, were the black regions of the source image. It turns out the Sony deck will not encode the very lowest values of black. I must quickly note that a standard broadcast signal will not contain these black levels and the Viper footage didn't either, and that is why SR is closer to the CineForm quality for the live footage. This black level issue will only come up for content meant for theatrical presentation--a film-out master, just like the StEM footage if designed to stress test. Now the amount of black truncation is not huge, but enough to explain the 2-3 dB drop in measured quality performance. Can anyone tell me why the whole 0 to 1023 range isn't recorded when the same range is valid over HDSDI/dual link?
While the original tests are valid, if we accounted for HDCAM-SR black levels by limiting the range of the source material, the difference would be less significant. Our original goal for these tests was to prove a software wavelet compressor can be as good as the best and most widely accepting compression solution. This we have achieved. But I will also acknowledge that with the two formats so close in quality, there will be some sequences that will favor SR over CineForm. I leave it up to others to find those sequences for their own comparisons. ;)
update April 30, 2007: I was just informed that it is a dual link HDSDI, not HDCAM-SR, that limits the valid range to only 4-1019. As we were only testing a file based workflow with CineForm 444, I re-ran the PSNR analysis only using the 4-1019 data range by clamping the extreme values. Surprisingly I found the PSNR numbers for SR only moved up a very small amount, far less than the 2-3dB I had predicted. The highly detailed StEM footage does seem to favor CineForm, likely due to our VBR nature versus the SR's CBR design, and the black levels where just a red herring.
update May 12, 2007: I have recently learned that the OminTek operator was Mike Hodson, the company founder and designer of the OmniTek PQA. So the testing was in very good hands.
Thursday, April 19, 2007
NAB Stuff -- CML Party
I'm back from NAB with a lot of exciting work to do -- funny how we are so busy to prepare for this show, only to have a brand new list of tasks to complete immediately after it. I skipped the last day, which is typically quieter, to get a head start on my to-do list. The show was exhausting as usual, but all indications are a very positive experience for CineForm and out booth partners (Wafian & Silicon Imaging.) The important thing was I was there long enough to attend the CML party.
This party is a geekfest of cameras in a shootout, plus beer and pizza. Thanks are well-deserved to Scott Billups and Geoff Boyle for organizing the event. There were cameras from Panavision, Sony,Panasonic, Silicon Imaging, Phantom & Canon (HV20 -- no joke was in the shoot-out vs a Phantom 65 and Genesis.) Capture gear was provided by Rave HD, Wafian and Codex. Pictures tell a lot.![]()

![]()









Sunday, April 15, 2007
Apple catching on, proves CineForm right.
Several years ago, CineForm attempted to sell Apple on the idea of a digital intermediate codec for professional post. Unfortunately, back then they still had their heads stuck firmly in the DV sand, and believed DVCPRO-HD would be sufficient, which everyone today knows it isn't. With the announcement of Apple ProRes 422, it seems the CineForm message has finally taken some hold, but it seems only as far as offering an equivalent to Avid's DNxHD (good for CineForm.) It seems to be a DCT codec with nearly identical data rates to the Avid codec, 1080p24 is quoted at 22 MB/s or 176Mb/s (same as Avid.) It might be wishful thinking if the Apple codec is a CBR design like Avid's; I guess we will have to wait and see. Funny thing, with all our recent work on a 4:4:4 codec, it's like we knew this was coming. :)